Wednesday, September 28, 2011

BO0K VS M0ViE: H0LES


Many books these days are made into movies so more of the public will enjoy the story. Some popular examples today are Harry Potter, The Twilight series, and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. But it is wondered how hundred paged novels can be transformed into a quick two hour film? Obviously, the directors have a lot of editing to do, and the story is altered a bit so the story fits in the time frame. Many people seem to think that a novel is much better than its movie, but some would rather prefer to watch the movie because it sums up the whole story much quicker. Many pages of a book can be portrayed in a movie in a matter of seconds. The book Holes by Louis Sachar is one I read as a child then also watched a movie as. There were many changes of events in the movie than stated in the book. What you see in a movie may not be the same as how you imagined when reading its book. 
Holes by Louis Sachar is a book about a young boy Stanley Yelnats, that is sent to a juvenile detention facility called Camp Green Lake. He was accused of stealing a famous baseball players shoes at a charity auction. Turns out the “Lake” is not exactly a lake, anymore. The setting is a great dry desert where the boys much dig holes daily as their punishment. They find out that this area contains buried gold from hundreds of years ago.
            In the book Holes, details were much more deeply portrayed in the characters and events. Also many characteristics and events were changed in comparison to the book and movie. An example is in the book, Stanley, the main character was described as a chubby boy, that was constantly concerned about his weight, but in the movie, he shows as a skinny boy. Also In the film, the roles of Mr. Sir and Mr. Pendanski slightly swap: Mr. Sir is the one who saves Stanley after he digs his first hole and expresses his concern when Stanley runs away. Another example of changes made is the film more dramatically depicts the huge hole, showing a network of tunnels. The book simply says that three holes came together until it was one. Small changes like a characters position in a scene or a characters car can sometimes really make a difference, and other times not even be noticed.
            Novels to movies can be very different from each other. Sometimes it is done purposely by the directors for different reasons. Small changes are made sometimes to make the story flow better, because sometimes since a long story can be difficult to be compacted together in a quick summary, changes must be made to make it easier on the cast and directors of the movie. Also the book contents may change during a film making solely because that book won’t work so well in a movie. If you think about it, making a story that can takes days to finish into one that takes two hours, takes a lot of work and requires many changes. Another reason why a director may change the story in a movie is just because they want to show a piece of themselves in their work. As you can see, there can be many different reasons why a director changes the characters or events in a story during a movie but in my opinion it is for the better and must be done. I usually think that they do a good job in portraying all the important aspects from the book into a movie, but it also would be nice to see the whole nine yards in the movie as well.

No comments:

Post a Comment